Best Almond Butter for 2022 (Reviews and Buyer’s Guide)

Best Almond Butter Featured Image

If you’re looking for a mouthwatering and nutritious nut butter spread, you might want to give almond butter a try. Spread it on toast or even eat it by the spoonful—the options are endless. 

However, finding the best almond butter without additives is challenging. Luckily, we tried the best of the best products worth your time and money. Check out the rest for the details on how these products perform.

A Brief Overview of the Top Products

Product
Rating
Key Features
Website
OVERALL RATING
9.7
Expert Review
  • Ultra-creamy texture
  • Perfectly thick consistency
  • Doesn't contain added salt
FROM: $ 11.29
Visit Site
OVERALL RATING
9.9
Expert Review
  • Great for satisfying sweet tooth
  • Children will love it
  • Stir-free
FROM: $ 10.17
Visit Site
OVERALL RATING
9.8
Expert Review
  • Won’t kick you out of ketosis
  • Crunchiness enhances flavor
  • Excellent spreadability
FROM: $ 23.92
Visit Site
OVERALL RATING
10
Expert Review
  • Great for low-sodium dieters
  • Pairs well with any fruit
  • Peanut-free
FROM: $ 11.95
Visit Site
OVERALL RATING
9.6
Expert Review
  • Good for bulk buyers
  • Works great in sauces
  • Filler-free
FROM: $ 12.39
Visit Site

Reviews of the Top-Rated Almond Butter

Justin’s Classic Almond Butter

OVERALL RATING 9.7
  • Editor’s pick: Top-selling all-natural option
  • Package size: 16oz jar (454g)
  • Ingredients: Dry-roasted almonds, palm oil
  • Texture: Creamy
  • Shipping: Shipping fees apply
  • Price: $11.29

When buying the best quality product, you want to look for almond butter with only natural ingredients. Luckily, Justin’s Classic Almond Butter doesn’t contain artificial ingredients or trans fats. Instead, it contains organic dry-roasted almonds and palm fruit oil (sustainably sourced). Although we’d prefer if the ingredients only listed almonds, this product makes up for this with its taste and texture.

Most importantly, if you’re looking for almond butter without sugar, this is a good choice for you. Not only is it free of added sugar, but it’s also gluten-free, paleo, vegan/vegetarian, dairy-free, and preservative-free. 

Now, since the product is manufactured in a facility that handles peanuts, people with peanut allergies will want to look elsewhere. Overall, this is a good almond butter brand, especially if you’re on a budget. As mentioned, texture-wise, it’s ultra-creamy, and the taste is rich.

PROS:
  • Ultra-creamy texture
  • Perfectly thick consistency
  • Doesn't contain added salt
CONS:
  • Contains palm oil

MaraNatha Natural California Almond Butter

OVERALL RATING 9.9
  • Editor’s pick: Most delicious almond butter
  • Package size: 12oz (340g)
  • Ingredients: Almonds, palm oil, evaporated cane sugar, sea salt
  • Texture: Crunchy
  • Shipping: Shipping fees apply
  • Price: $10.17

If you’re looking for the tastiest almond butter that will satisfy your craving for sweets, we recommend the MaraNatha Natural California Almond Butter. This product is rich in flavor and texture, and it will most likely appeal to people who have a sweet tooth. Namely, the formula contains evaporated cane sugar that boosts the flavor of the almond butter to a new level. 

Of course, if you prefer almond butter with a more natural flavor, this might not be the best choice for you. With that in mind, when it comes to this almond butter, its cost is quite affordable. Considering this product is non-GMO, gluten-free, and kosher, you’re getting excellent quality for a low price.

We also liked that it’s stir-free. This means that you can enjoy this butter straight from the jar without having to mix it vigorously. All in all, this might be the cheapest almond butter that can boast this level of quality.

PROS:
  • Great for satisfying sweet tooth
  • Children will love it
  • Stir-free
CONS:
  • Contains added sugar

Once Again Organic Almond Butter

OVERALL RATING 9.8
  • Editor’s pick: Popular choice for ketogenic diet
  • Package size: 16oz (454g)
  • Ingredients: Organic almonds
  • Texture: Crunchy
  • Shipping: Shipping fees apply
  • Price: $23.92

If you’re on a strict ketogenic diet, you want to avoid added ingredients that will kick you out of ketosis. Fortunately, the Once Again Organic Almond Butter contains only organic almonds without added sugar, salt, or unnecessary carbs. As a result, you’ll enjoy all of the health benefits of almonds without spiking your blood sugar.

One of the main things we enjoy about this allnatural almond butter is the taste. Since it’s unsweetened and lightly toasted, you only get almonds’ most natural, rich aroma. Although it has a crunchy texture, it’s not gritty. The reason for this is that the formula contains unblanched, finely-milled almonds. 

Overall, this is one of the rare keto almond butter brands that deliver precisely what you order. On the downside, some customers complained about finding small pieces of almond shells in the butter. Fortunately, these complaints were extremely rare, and the consumers were typically able to easily identify and remove the shells before actually eating them.

PROS:
  • Won’t kick you out of ketosis
  • Crunchiness enhances flavor
  • Excellent spreadability
CONS:
  • Potential presence of small pieces of almond shells

Barney Bare Almond Butter

OVERALL RATING 10
  • Editor’s pick: One of the best-rated brands
  • Package size: 16oz (454g)
  • Ingredients: Blanched roasted almonds, palm fruit oil
  • Texture: Bare smooth
  • Shipping: Shipping fees apply
  • Price: $11.95

According to customers, there are many reasons why the Barney Bare Almond Butter is one of the highest-rated almond butter products. First of all, it’s free of added sugar and salt, making it a suitable option for people on low sugar and low sodium diets. Also, it doesn’t contain any traces of peanuts, making it a good choice for consumers with allergies.

This toasted almond butter also excels in flavor. The blanched, roasted almonds taste natural and rich. Unfortunately, this product also contains palm fruit oil. However, not everyone minds this, especially since this ingredient makes the texture even better. 

Another thing we noticed with this roasted almond butter is that it’s a bit oily and requires some mixing before consumption. But, when you stir it up, the spreadability is great. On the positive side, this product will likely appeal to people who prefer the almond skins removed.

PROS:
  • Great for low-sodium dieters
  • Pairs well with any fruit
  • Peanut-free
CONS:
  • Requires some mixing

Kirkland Creamy Almond Butter

OVERALL RATING 9.6
  • Editor’s pick: Excellent palm-oil-free almond butter
  • Package size: 27oz (765g)
  • Ingredients: Roasted almonds
  • Texture: Creamy
  • Shipping: Shipping fees apply
  • Price: $12.39

If you’re on the lookout for the ideal almond butter without palm oil, you’ll likely enjoy the Kirkland Creamy Almond Butter. The sole ingredient in this product is roasted almonds finely ground into a lusciously creamy spread. As a result, you get a rich almond butter that retains the inherent nutritional value. 

The almond butter is also made in a peanut-free facility, making it suitable for people with allergies. So, you can see why Kirkland is commonly dubbed the healthiest almond butter brand. Naturally, there are no added sugars or sodium in the formula. Although the flavor might be a bit bland for some people, the natural creaminess is ideal for others.

This is also a good choice if you’re planning to buy almond butter in bulk—for a low price, you get a lot of product. On the downside, some customers note that the consistency could be thicker. However, the runny texture is excellent if you plan to add it to smoothies or sauces.

PROS:
  • Good for bulk buyers
  • Works great in sauces
  • Filler-free
CONS:
  • Could be thicker

How to Choose the Best Almond Butter

Not every almond butter is healthy. Some products you can find at stores are filled with unnecessary additives, hidden ingredients, and added sugar or salt. To get the most bang for your buck, you’ll need to study the nutrition label carefully. Here are some ways to find the healthiest almond butter on the shelves.

Scan the Nutrition Label

Before making a purchase, you’ll need to check the ingredients label for suspicious additives. Ideally, you should look for almond butter made with only one ingredient—almonds. Products that feature only almonds are typically of good quality. 

Unsweetened almond butter is the way to go, especially if you want to cut sugar. Unfortunately, many conventional brands contain heaps of added sugar, artificial flavorings, and other potentially harmful ingredients.

If you prefer sweetened almond butter, choose products sweetened naturally with honey, agave, or maple syrup. As for lowcal almond butter, you can look for products with zero-calorie sweeteners or even sweeten them on your own with your favorite stevia brand. However, remember that almond butter is naturally calorie-dense, so you’ll also need to be mindful of portion control.

Consider Other Nutritious Ingredients

Nowadays, you can find almond butter products supercharged with other nutrient-dense ingredients such as hemp, chia, and flax seeds. You’ll also come across some almond butter brands that feature organic goji, cacao nibs, and similar ingredients.

Overall, most almond butter reviews agree that superfoods are a great addition to your almond butter. That being said, experts recommend skipping butters that include coconut oil, as these products are high in saturated fat. If you want to get that coconut flavor, instead, try sprinkling shredded coconut on the butter.

Choose the Right Texture

Whether you’ll go with creamy almond butter, chunky, or slightly grainy, the choice is up to you. Traditional nut butters have a smooth and thick texture, while all-natural varieties tend to be grainy. To achieve a smooth look, brands usually use skinless almonds.

Dietary Preferences

You’ll notice that some products are labeled halal, kosher, gluten-free, dairy-free, paleo, and vegan. If you have specific dietary requirements, you’ll want to look for a good almond butter with some or all of these labels.

Benefits of Almond Butter

As mentioned, almond butter is full of heart-healthy fats and it’s a good source of protein. It’s also a source of omega-3 fatty acids, which are essential for preventing irregular heart rhythms. If you’re not eating enough vitamin E foods, you can also get your daily dose of this vitamin and L-arginine (beneficial for the walls in arteries) from a serving of quality almond butter.

Moreover, fresh almond butter is high in calcium, a vital nutrient for all ages, especially the elderly. In fact, elderly nutrition guidelines show that people over 50 should aim for 1,200 mg of calcium per day. In one serving of almond butter, you get around 60 mg of calcium for bone health. Besides, almond butter is good for blood sugar control and healthy weight gain.

The Bottom Line

Clearly, there’s a wide selection of almond butter products you can choose from. Overall, look for natural almond butter with one main ingredient—almonds. You can also play around with flavorful varieties and different textures. 

You may be a fan of crunchy almond butter, or perhaps the smooth texture is your preference. Whatever the case may be, avoid added sugar, sodium, and harmful additives.

FAQs

What is the best-tasting almond butter?

All of the almond butters featured in our article are delicious, but our favorite is MaraNatha’s Natural California Almond Butter. Thanks to the high-quality almonds and evaporated cane sugar, it has a distinct nutty flavor with a hint of sweetness.

Is almond butter the healthiest butter?

According to some, almond butter is the healthiest nut butter, thanks to the healthy monounsaturated fats, decent protein content, and nutrients like vitamin E. Just make sure you choose an all-natural type of almond butter because these will provide you with all the benefits.

Is organic almond butter worth it?

Yes, organically made almond butter is worth the money. It’s nutritionally dense and typically better in flavor. But, overall, the best almond butter for you will be the one that meets all your nutritional needs without leaving your taste buds disappointed.