Best Crib Mattress in 2020 (Reviews & Buyer’s Guide)

Best Crib Mattresses

When you’re preparing your nursery for a baby, there are many items you know you’re going to need to buy. And whether you’re a new parent or have done this before, you’ll want to thoroughly vet most of the products you buy for your baby.

That’s why we’re here to help you choose the best crib mattress for your little one. We picked out the top 10 crib mattresses and then composed a quick review of each one. Each is rated according to comfort, quality, safety, and value.

The Top 10 Best Crib Mattress Options on the Market

Product
Rating
Key Features
Website
1
OVERALL RATING
9.9
Expert Review
  • Waterproof and easy to clean
  • Choice between lightweight and innerspring
  • Firm side for babies and medium-firm for toddlers
  • Lifetime warranty
FROM: $ 259.00
Visit Site
2
OVERALL RATING
9.8
Expert Review
  • Ultra-breathable
  • Completely supportive
  • 100% safe and chemical-free
  • Lifetime warranty
FROM: $ 299.99
Visit Site
3
OVERALL RATING
9.7
Expert Review
  • 120 heavy-duty coils
  • Reinforced edge support
  • CertiPUR-US approved
  • 35-year warranty
FROM: $ 259.99
Visit Site
4
OVERALL RATING
9.7
Expert Review
  • 204 innerspring coils
  • Excellent support for baby
  • Durable, easy-to-clean cover
  • 10-year warranty
FROM: $ 179.99
Visit Site
5
OVERALL RATING
9.6
Expert Review
  • Excellent airflow
  • Polyurethane to ensure it stays dry
  • Organic
  • Infant side is perfectly firm
FROM: $ 259.00
Visit Site
6
OVERALL RATING
9.5
Expert Review
  • Best affordable crib mattress
  • Two hypoallergenic layers
  • Great airflow
  • 30-day warranty
FROM: $ 42.19
Visit Site
7
OVERALL RATING
9.5
Expert Review
  • Core is recyclable
  • Non-toxic and vegan
  • Removable cover
  • 10-year warranty on core
FROM: $ 199.00
Visit Site
8
OVERALL RATING
9.4
Expert Review
  • Three color options
  • Super lightweight
  • Comfortable pebble design
  • Lifetime warranty
FROM: $ 199.00
Visit Site
9
OVERALL RATING
9.4
Expert Review
  • Takes measures to be more eco-friendly
  • Solid but lightweight
  • 100% safe mattress
  • Lifetime warranty
FROM: $ 209.99
Visit Site
10
OVERALL RATING
9.3
Expert Review
  • Affordable option
  • Waterproof bamboo cover
  • Sturdy structure
  • 30-day money-back guarantee
FROM: $ 99.00
Visit Site

Top 10 Crib Mattress Reviews

  • Price: $259.00–$299.00
  • Type: Lightweight or innerspring
  • Warranty: Lifetime limited warranty
  • Shipping Policy: Free shipping
  • Trial Period: 30 days

There are three options for the Naturepedic Classic Organic Baby Crib Mattress: lightweight, lightweight 2-stage, and innerspring 2-stage. All three are contenders for the best crib mattress in 2020

Both lightweight options have a wavesupport core, making them easy to lift. The innerspring option has 150 coils and is much heavier. The 2-Stage options, either in the lightweight or the innerspring, have a firm side for babies (even firmer than a mattress designed for back pain) and a medium-firm side for toddlers. This means these can be used for years to come. 

Whichever option you choose, the cover is made from an organic cotton fabric with waterproofing that makes it super easy to clean. Another feature making this the best baby crib mattress is the filling. It’s made from organic cotton fill and has a PLA layer (on the toddler side if you choose a 2-stage mattress), which is resilient and completely free from harmful chemicals.

PROS:
  • Waterproof and easy to clean
  • Choice between lightweight and innerspring
  • Firm side for babies and medium-firm for toddlers
CONS:
  • Lightweight option is less firm
  • Price: $299.99
  • Type: Wovenaire core and food-grade polymer
  • Warranty: Lifetime limited warranty
  • Shipping Policy: Free shipping
  • Trial Period: 100-night trial

The Newton Baby Crib Mattress is one of the best crib mattresses on the market today. While it isn’t an entirely organic mattress, it’s 100% safe and made without using any chemicals, which is a number-one concern for many new parents. It’s also Greenguard Gold certified. 

This mattress includes a 3-D space cover, which is like a soft quilted cloud, ensuring that your little can snuggle all night long. It’s made from polyester, meaning it’s ultra-breathable and easy to wash. 

The center of this top-rated crib mattress has a Wovenaire core, making it incredibly supportive and offering a good bounce. This unique material is produced from plastic threads that are pushed together so they’re almost solid. These materials together ensure that your little one can regulate their temperature and sleep comfortably through the night.

PROS:
  • Ultra-breathable
  • Completely supportive
  • 100% safe and chemical-free
CONS:
  • Expensive compared to similar choices
  • Price: $259.99
  • Type: Innerspring and gel memory foam
  • Warranty: 35-year warranty
  • Shipping Policy: Free shipping
  • Trial Period: N/A

If you’ve ever owned a Serta mattress, you know what sort of quality to expect with the Tranquility Eco Select Crib and Toddler Mattress. Although this is nearly the best mattress for kids, it’s made using the same mastery as Serta’s traditional adult mattresses. The brand took everything that worked well for its other mattresses to create a firm crib mattress, including the wonderful edge support.

This mattress uses an innerspring system made up of 120 coils that are created using heavy-duty metal. The innerspring is on the infant side of the mattress. It offers the exact firmness needed for a baby. On the other side of this best-rated crib mattress is gel memory foam, which gives a slightly softer (but still completely supportive) feel for a toddler.

It’s important to note that this crib mattress is CertiPUR-US approved and Greenguard Gold certified. Needless to say, it’s 100% safe for your little one.

PROS:
  • 120 heavy-duty coils
  • Reinforced edge support
  • CertiPUR-US approved
CONS:
  • On the expensive side
  • Price: $179.99
  • Type: Soybean foam and innerspring
  • Warranty: 10-year warranty
  • Shipping Policy: Free shipping
  • Trial Period: N/A

This crib mattress from Sealy is definitely one of the leading top-rated crib mattresses on the market today, and for a good reason. The cover is a durable cotton blend and super easy to clean, which is needed when you have a baby. This cover uses Crypton Clean Sleep (Greenguard certified), which is stain-proof and forms a barrier for liquids, so you won’t end up with a stained mattress.

The inside of this mattress has both soybean foam and 204 steel innerspring coils to ensure that your baby will have all the support they need. Of course, if you flip the mattress, you’ll find that the other side is just a little bit softer to support a growing toddler. Both sides have reinforced edge support to ensure your child won’t dip into the sides.

PROS:
  • 204 innerspring coils
  • Excellent support for baby
  • Durable, easy-to-clean cover
CONS:
  • No trial period
  • Price: $259.00
  • Type: Foam
  • Warranty: No warranty
  • Shipping Policy: Free shipping
  • Trial Period: N/A

The Breeze Air 2-Stage mattress from Lullaby Earth is a contender for the best organic crib mattress. It’s truly a great choice for anyone with an infant as they can keep the mattress for years as their baby becomes a toddler. The baby side is super firm, which is ideal, and the toddler side is a little softer.

What’s great about the cover is that it won’t let any moisture in, which can be an issue with some other crib mattresses. The outer shell also has great airflow, ensuring that your little one won’t feel too hot at night. It also comes with a mattress protector to prevent the mattress from staining.

On the inside are six inches of foam in a honeycomb structure. Organic crib mattress reviews note that this structure keeps the foam from overheating.

PROS:
  • Excellent airflow
  • Polyurethane to ensure it stays dry
  • Organic
CONS:
  • No warranty
  • Price: $42.19
  • Type: Pocket coil
  • Warranty: 30-day warranty
  • Shipping Policy: Free shipping
  • Trial Period: N/A

This crib mattress from Dream on Me is the best cheap crib mattress on our list. So if you’re looking for a way to save on a crib mattress without sacrificing your little one’s comfort, then you’ve come to the right place.

The heat-tempered coils give your baby the support they need at a young age. They definitely won’t sink into this mattress, which can be dangerous for infants. And the mattress cover is breathable, offering sufficient airflow so your baby won’t overheat in their sleep. Rest assured that this portable mattress is Greenguard Gold certified, so it’s completely safe. 

This is also a great size for use in a bassinet or other portable baby carrier, so your little one can sleep on the go. You won’t have to worry about their comfort or safety.

PROS:
  • Best affordable crib mattress
  • Two hypoallergenic layers
  • Great airflow
CONS:
  • Only has a 30-day warranty
  • Price: $199.00
  • Type: Polyester
  • Warranty: 10-year warranty on core; 1-year warranty on cover
  • Shipping Policy: Free shipping
  • Trial Period: N/A

If you’re looking for a mattress that meets all your vegan standards, then this crib mattress from Babyletto is perfect for you. As the best non-toxic crib mattress out there, no animals were harmed in its production. What’s more, it contains zero polyurethane or soy foam, dyes, chemical fire deterrents, vinyl, phthalates, materials that result in off-gassing, non-natural latex, PFCs, or anything that could cause an allergic reaction.

This mattress is just the right size for a crib and has squared corners for a snug fit. The infant side of this mattress is just the right firmness level for a baby—your little one won’t sink in at all. The toddler side of this is slightly less firm, which is great for a growing child.

It provides practically the best crib mattress cover out there—it’s waterproof and you can easily remove it to wash it.

PROS:
  • Core is recyclable
  • Non-toxic and vegan
  • Removable cover
CONS:
  • Cover only protected by one-year warranty
  • Price: $199.00
  • Type: Foam
  • Warranty: Lifetime warranty
  • Shipping Policy: Free shipping
  • Trial Period: N/A

Although looks aren’t the topmost priority when it comes to choosing from the best mattresses for kids, the Nook Sleep Pebble Air Ultra Lite Crib Mattress has a unique design that lets it suit any nursery’s aesthetic. Of course, this crib mattress is also an exceptional choice for new parents because it’s super comfortable, the right level of firmness, extra breathable, and lightweight. 

This crib mattress has a number of independent certifications, including Greenguard Gold, Oeko-Tex Standard 100, Bluesign system for sustainable textile production, Global Organic Textile Standard, and FSC. This means that this is one of the best crib mattresses in 2020 for people who truly care about the environment.  

When it comes to the cover, with its unique pebble design, you can choose between three different colors: blush, cloud, and sea glass. Whichever you choose, the inside remains the same, including the high-quality CertiPUR-US certified foam core.

PROS:
  • Three color options
  • Super lightweight
  • Comfortable pebble design
CONS:
  • Cover can be difficult to remove
  • Price: $209.99
  • Type: Foam
  • Warranty: Lifetime warranty
  • Shipping Policy: Free shipping
  • Trial Period: N/A

The Eco Classica III 2-Stage Baby and Toddler Mattress is a contender for the best infant crib mattress on the market. 

While it isn’t entirely 100% eco-friendly, the company takes several steps to make sure that it’s as safe for the environment as it can be. This includes being Greenguard Gold certified, using CertiPUR-US certified foam, and using organic cotton for the cover. The foam is even made from sustainable plant oils. The end result is perfectly safe for your little one. 

As a dual-stage mattress, you can use it when your child is an infant and also when they’re a toddler, and each side is clearly marked with a tag. The baby side of the mattress is firm enough to ensure that your baby won’t sink in, while the toddler side is just a little softer but still much firmer than a regular mattress. This could also well be the best breathable crib mattress on our list.

PROS:
  • Takes measures to be more eco-friendly
  • Solid but lightweight
  • 100% safe mattress
CONS:
  • Limited size option
  • Price: $99.00
  • Type: Foam
  • Warranty: No warranty
  • Shipping Policy: Free shipping
  • Trial Period: 30-day money-back guarantee

This is a premium memory foam crib mattress that only costs $99, which compares favorably with many of the other options on this list. After all, the best mattress for a baby crib shouldn’t necessarily break the bank.

This mattress is completely safe and comfortable for your little one. It’s also flippable, so it has a firm side for your infant and a slightly softer side for when they become a toddler. This means it will last for a few years before you have to change beds, saving you even more money.

The bamboo cover can easily be removed to wash, so you won’t end up with stains ruining the mattress. It’s also hypoallergenic, so your little one will be saved from any allergic reactions. This makes it a contender for the best waterproof crib mattress cover

And on the inside, you’ll find CertiPUR-US certified memory foam that’s been tested for low VOC, and it has absolutely no heavy metals.

PROS:
  • An affordable option
  • Waterproof bamboo cover
  • Sturdy structure
CONS:
  • No warranty

How to Choose the Best Crib Mattress for Your Little One

Choosing a crib mattress can be a very difficult decision. There are so many options on the market. You obviously want the best possible option for your little one, but you also don’t want to break the bank for a mediocre product. 

And this is why we’re here to help you out. Look out for the following when buying a crib mattress:

Go for Quality, Always

Whether you’re checking out the best organic crib mattresses or crib mattresses with the highest safety ratings, you should always make sure the products are made from quality materials. 

When it comes to your baby’s safety, you want to ensure you have only the best. And remember, a good crib mattress should be designed to help prevent Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS).

Buy a New Crib Mattress

You shouldn’t buy a secondhand crib mattress unless you know exactly how the first one was treated throughout its use. If you don’t know how a crib mattress was treated, you may find that there are damaged areas on the sleep surface or even mold growing without you knowing. It’s better to buy new when it comes to choosing the best crib mattress for your baby.

Make Sure It’s Firm Enough

Test the crib mattress’s firmness. It should feel hard and uncomfortable to you. Your baby shouldn’t sink into the mattress at all. Otherwise, they may end up suffocating. If you buy a dual-stage mattress, then the toddler side can be slightly softer, but not by much. 

Do the Two-Finger Test

Crib mattress reviews will often tell you that a crib mattress needs to be a specific size: 27.25″ x 51.25″. If you’re unsure about whether you have the right size, place the mattress in the crib and stick your fingers in the space between the crib and the mattress. If you can fit more than two fingers in, then you have the wrong size.  

Final Thoughts

Buying a crib mattress for your baby should be a top priority when you’re expecting. It’s where they’ll be spending most of their time as an infant, after all. This is why you want to choose the greatest crib mattress available on the market. We hope you’ve found our reviews and tips helpful and that you’ll find the perfect product for you and your little one.

FAQs

Can babies sleep on a memory foam mattress?

Babies cannot sleep on a regular mattress because it won’t be firm enough. However, there are many crib mattresses made from memory foam, and these are perfectly safe for babies.

How high should a crib mattress be for a newborn?

A crib mattress for a baby should never be any thicker than six inches. Anything up to six inches should be perfectly safe.

Which crib mattress is best?

The Naturepedic Classic Organic Baby Crib Mattress has our vote when it comes to choosing the best crib mattress. It’s a mix of quality materials, breathability, and durability. It also comes with a lifetime warranty. However, any of the other crib mattresses on our list would also be an excellent choice.