Best Maple Syrup for 2021 (Reviews & Buyer’s Guide)

Best Maple Syrup

Maple syrup is a pantry staple in every pancake lover’s home. The sweet and rich golden syrup is equally good on sweet and savory dishes. But, how do you find the best maple syrup in the sea of companies that make it? Well, get your credit card ready because this is your lucky day! We tried and tested a bunch of maple syrups, so you don’t have to. We then compiled a list of the best offers based on their:

  • Quality
  • Taste
  • Origin
  • Ingredients

So, read on to discover your new favorite maple syrup and make your life a little sweeter!

10 Best Maple Syrup Brands of 2021

Product
Rating
Key Features
Website
OVERALL RATING
10
Expert Review
  • Best overall
  • Ethically sourced
  • Certified kosher
  • Silky and natural taste
FROM: $ 14.95
Visit Site
OVERALL RATING
9.9
Expert Review
  • Best for the keto diet
  • No cruddy aftertaste
  • Gluten-free and non-GMO
  • No refrigeration required
FROM: $ 7.99
Visit Site
OVERALL RATING
9.8
Expert Review
  • Canada’s finest maple syrup
  • Distinct, round, and textured
  • Pure and unblended
  • USDA-certified organic
FROM: $ 23.99
Visit Site
OVERALL RATING
9.7
Expert Review
  • Most trusted brand
  • No spill, waste, or refrigeration
  • Among real maple syrup brands that are organic and QAI-certified
  • Harvested sustainably
FROM: $ 14.40
Visit Site
OVERALL RATING
9.6
Expert Review
  • Most organic
  • Artisan quality
  • Bold and intense flavor
  • 100% pure, kosher, and organic
FROM: $ 25.82
Visit Site
OVERALL RATING
9.5
Expert Review
  • Biggest selection of flavors
  • Versatile maple syrup use
  • Light bodied, but rich taste
  • The glass bottle preserves flavors
FROM: $ 16.95
Visit Site
OVERALL RATING
9.4
Expert Review
  • Best for waffles and pancakes
  • Available in a gallon jug
  • Sweet, but not overpowering taste
  • The best store-bought maple syrup with great value for money
FROM: $ 7.99
Visit Site
OVERALL RATING
9.3
Expert Review
  • Best bourbon barrel maple syrup
  • Handcrafted specialty syrup
  • Perfectly balanced flavors
  • No alcohol content
FROM: $ 24.99
Visit Site
OVERALL RATING
9.2
Expert Review
  • Best on-the-go maple syrup for your overall wellbeing
  • Convenient “tear open” packaging
  • Easily dissolves in water
  • Good replacement for energy gels
FROM: $ 36.95
Visit Site
OVERALL RATING
9.1
Expert Review
  • Best for the paleo diet
  • A unique blend of flavors
  • Gives food and drinks a twist
  • Organic cinnamon from Indonesia
FROM: $ 13.99
Visit Site

In-depth Maple Syrup Reviews

Thrive Market Organic Maple Syrup

OVERALL RATING 10
  • Editor’s Choice: Overall Best Maple Syrup
  • Syrup Grade: Grade A Dark; Organic
  • Available in: 12, 16, and 32 fl oz jug
  • Bottling: BPA-free plastic
  • Origin: Vermont, US
  • Price: From $14.95 for a 12 fl oz jug

Real maple syrup connoisseurs will love this deep-colored, rich-flavored maple syrup. Thrive Market maple syrup gets its authentic taste straight from wild-grown maple trees in Vermont.

The syrup is one of the darkest on the market and packs a rich and robust flavor. What we love the most about it is that it has only one ingredient — pure maple syrup.

There are no additives, GMOs, preservatives, or other harmful compounds. The syrup comes in a plastic bottle, but it’s BPA-free, so there’s nothing to worry about. 

You can choose between a squeeze bottle and a classic maple syrup jug. The smaller bottles are convenient to take on picnics or camping. The larger jugs are an excellent option if you have a large pancake-loving family. However, it’s so delicious that we don’t guarantee it’ll last you a long time.

PROS:
  • Ethically sourced
  • Certified kosher
  • Silky and natural taste
CONS:
  • The consistency is a bit runny

ChocZero Keto Maple Syrup

OVERALL RATING 9.9
  • Editor’s Choice: Best Keto Maple Syrup
  • Syrup Grade: N/A; Not Organic
  • Available in: 12 fl oz
  • Bottling: Plastic
  • Origin: California, US
  • Price: From $7.99 for a 12 fl oz bottle

We strongly suggest that you look into ChockZero if you’re on a low-carb diet. With its creative and product team led by someone who lost 150 lbs on the keto diet, ChockZero aims to offer the best sugarfree maple syrup for everyone looking for healthier ingredients.

But, how can maple syrup be sugar-free if it’s a natural sweetener? Easy! The company uses a combination of natural maple flavoring and monk fruit extract to create a thick and sweet but sugar-free syrup.

Now, it doesn’t have the signature deep flavor of a real maple syrup. However, its thick and buttery taste makes it by far the besttasting sugarfree maple syrup replacement.

It’s an excellent option if you want to give your keto shakes a little bit of oomph and sweetness without upsetting your stomach and endangering your health. Just add some ChockZero syrup and chug it all in a blender of your choice — and you’re good to go.

PROS:
  • No cruddy aftertaste
  • Non-GMO and gluten-free
  • No refrigeration required
CONS:
  • Contains resistant dextrin (from corn husk fiber), which might not be as appreciated by those on a stricter keto diet

Escuminac Great Harvest Maple Syrup

OVERALL RATING 9.8
  • Editor’s Choice: Best Canadian Maple Syrup
  • Syrup Grade: Grade A Dark; Organic
  • Available in: 16.9 fl oz
  • Bottling: Glass
  • Origin: Quebec, Canada
  • Price: From $23.99 for a 16.9 fl oz bottle

Now, let’s travel a little up north to treat ourselves to rich and textured maple syrup. 

Escuminac is one of the best Canadian maple syrup brands with decades of experience in making maple syrup and multiple awards that prove the quality.

Its maple syrup has a distinct, balanced taste that won’t overwhelm you with heavy sweetness. Its robust taste matches almost any type of food. It’s versatile and great for anything — from pancakes, waffles, salads, and roasted veggies to cocktails, lattes, and aromatic CBD coffee

It comes as no surprise that the syrup is this versatile as one simply cannot expect less from this Canadian, truly finest maple syrup.

The elegant glass packaging also makes it an excellent gift option for foodies. The wax seal will keep the flavor and aroma in the bottle. However, it’ll make it very hard to open the syrup.

The USDA certification will give you peace of mind. The syrup is non-GMO and organic, as well as free from additives and gluten.

PROS:
  • Distinct, round, and textured
  • Pure and unblended
  • USDA-certified organic
CONS:
  • The wax seal makes it difficult to open the bottle

Coombs Family Farms Maple Stream

OVERALL RATING 9.7
  • Editor’s Choice: Best Maple Syrup Brand
  • Syrup Grade: Grade A Amber; Organic
  • Available in: 7 fl oz
  • Bottling: Spray can
  • Origin: Vermont, US
  • Price: From $14.40 for a 7 fl oz can

Coombs Family Farms have been harvesting maple sap since 1840 in efforts to produce a high-quality, organic maple syrup. They’ve been carrying the title of America’s most trusted maple syrup brand for seven generations.

Their unique packaging will allow you to spray the exact amount of syrup over your waffles or directly in your cocktail without making a mess. The spray can also be useful when making cookies or spicing up your hot cocoa. Kids find it super-fun, and adults aren’t immune to its charm either.

What’s incredibly convenient is that you don’t even have to refrigerate this high-quality maple syrup after opening it. The can will protect the maple syrup from going bad quickly, and you won’t have to pour cold maple syrup over your morning pancakes anymore.

Besides being certified organic, the syrup is also certified kosher. It contains no artificial colors, flavors, or any other unhealthy compounds. Its robust and rich flavor characterizes it.

PROS:
  • No spill, waste, or refrigeration
  • QAI-certified organic
  • Harvested sustainably
CONS:
  • The spout sometimes gets clogged

Crown Maple Very Dark Maple Syrup

OVERALL RATING 9.6
  • Editor’s Choice: Best Organic Maple Syrup
  • Syrup Grade: Grade A Very Dark, Organic
  • Available in: 25 fl oz
  • Bottling: Glass bottles
  • Origin: New York and Vermont, US
  • Price: From $25.82

Crown Maple provides a gourmet experience from bark to bottle. The maple sap is sourced from the brand-owned estate that stretches from New York to Vermont, providing exceptional quality maple syrup.

Crown Maple has been one of the leading pure maple syrup brands for years. Its Very Dark Maple Syrup, formerly known as Grade B, offers a deep caramelized flavor. The syrup is perfect for sweetening hot chocolate, black tea, and deeply roasted coffee.

There are no artificial sweeteners and additives. What’s more, Maple Crown adds hints of clove, allspice, and anise, resulting in a refined, full-bodied taste, which makes the syrup stand out from other healthy maple syrup brands.  

The syrup comes in a gorgeous glass bottle, making it a convenient gift for any maple syrup lover, amateur chef, or gourmet you may know. Just be wary — the strong, dark flavor isn’t for everyone. It’s best suited for maple syrup connoisseurs and people who like experimenting with new food.

PROS:
  • Artisan quality
  • Bold and intense flavor
  • 100% pure, kosher, and organic
CONS:
  • The syrup might mold quickly

Runamok Maple Syrup

OVERALL RATING 9.5
  • Editor’s Choice: Best Maple Syrup With a Wide Range of Flavors
  • Syrup Grade: Grade A Amber; Organic
  • Available in: 8.45, 12.7, and 25.36 fl oz
  • Bottling: Glass
  • Origin: Vermont, US
  • Price: From $16.95 for an 8.45 bottle

Runamok has taken maple syrup making to a whole new level. The company makes organic, USDA-certified maple syrup of exceptional taste. Aged in rum, bourbon, and whiskey barrels, this maple syrup will transform any dish and drink. It’s equally great in ice cream as it is in cocktails.

Runamok is constantly trying out new recipes in the efforts to combine unique ingredients that will bring out the flavor of the syrup. Not only does it care about the maple syrup quality and its customers’ satisfaction, but it also protects the trees and makes efforts to keep the habitat healthy.

This toprated maple syrup comes in a number of flavors: cinnamon, cinnamon & vanilla, holiday spice, coffee, elderberry, jasmine, ginger root, and many others. 

On top of that, Runamok offers gift boxes that will make a perfect present for any foodie that appreciates deep but light-bodied maple flavor. Each bottle in such boxes carries 8.45 fl oz of unparalleled-tasting maple syrup. The bottles are gorgeous on their own, but Runamok packs them in an elegant gift box and turns gift-giving into a completely new experience.

PROS:
  • Versatile maple syrup use
  • Light bodied, but rich taste
  • The glass bottle preserves flavors
CONS:
  • Might develop a thin layer of mold after three months or so

Mount Mansfield Pure Vermont Maple Syrup

OVERALL RATING 9.4
  • Editor’s Choice: Best Maple Syrup for Pancakes
  • Syrup Grade: Grade A (Golden Delicate and Amber Rich) and Grade B (Dark Robust); Not certified organic
  • Available in: 8, 16, 32, and 64 fl oz
  • Bottling: BPA-free plastic
  • Origin: Vermont, US
  • Price: From $7.99 for an 8 fl oz jug

Like Coombs Family Farms, Mount Mansfield has provided users with top-quality maple syrup for several generations. This family-run maple syrup company is determined to exceed everyone’s expectations of maple syrup flavor, price, and overall quality.

Its products come in all grades and flavor intensity. Still, its Pure Vermont Maple Syrup is one of the best maple syrups you can pour over pancakes, waffles, and other mild foods. The syrup is available in classic jugs ranging from half a pint to two gallons, so everyone can find their perfect fit.

The syrup has a pure and clean taste, so it won’t overtake the dish’s flavor. It pairs well with both plain and flavored pancakes. The pancakes’ flavor remains dominant with just a hint of sweet maple that even picky eaters will love.

If you want the best price for maple syrup, go for the gallon jug option. It’s also a great solution if your breakfast consists of pancakes on most days.

PROS:
  • Available in a gallon jug
  • Sweet, but not overpowering taste
  • Great value for money
CONS:
  • It runs slightly thin

Bissell Maple Farm Bourbon Maple Syrup

OVERALL RATING 9.3
  • Editor’s Choice: Best Bourbon Maple Syrup
  • Syrup Grade: Grade A Dark; Organic
  • Available in: 12.7 fl oz
  • Bottling: Glass
  • Origin: Ohio, US
  • Price: From $24.99 for a 12.7 fl oz bottle

For over a century, the Bissell family has been hand-pouring and bottling its bourbon barrel-aged maple syrup. The family combines tradition, craftsmanship, and tested recipes to create the besttasting maple syrup.

In a nutshell, the Bissell family uses American oak bourbon barrels and lets its maple syrup rest in them for several months. Each barrel is used only once per batch to ensure the optimal flavor.

The result — dark, robust-tasting maple syrup with a bourbon and oak aroma. The flavors are balanced and don’t outshine one another but rather complement each other.

It’s among the most expensive maple syrups, but the quality you get is worth the price. The syrup will enrich the flavor of your oatmeal, waffles, ice cream, or drinks. And you don’t have to worry — there’s no alcohol in the syrup.

Finally, each cork is hand-dipped into the wax to create a sealing that will keep all the flavors and aromas in the bottle.

PROS:
  • Handcrafted specialty syrup
  • Perfectly balanced flavors
  • No alcohol content
CONS:
  • On the pricier side

UnTapped Maple Athletic Fuel Syrup

OVERALL RATING 9.2
  • Editor’s Choice: Healthiest Maple Syrup
  • Syrup Grade: Grade A Amber; Organic
  • Available in: 20 packets
  • Bottling: Individual packets
  • Origin: Vermont, the USA
  • Price: From $36.95 for a pack of 20 packets (0.96 fl oz each)

UnTapped has created a special packaging so that athletes can fuel up easily with maple syrup. The single-serving packaging is convenient to take on a run, to the gym, to a cycling session, or to complement other high-endurance activities. Just tear open the packaging, gulp down the sweet golden syrup, and keep working out!

It fits in a pocket so that you can take it anywhere to replenish your energy levels in seconds. There’s only one ingredient — the best real maple syrup.

The syrup keeps your blood sugar levels in the optimal range during the workout. Moreover, it causes no gastric distress. It also dissolves in water easily, if you prefer to mix it with other liquids.

But, you don’t have to be an athlete to use it. It’s plain maple syrup. You can take it when camping and pour it over pancakes, or you can chuck it in your bag and splash it in your coffee at work.

PROS:
  • Convenient “tear open” packaging
  • Easily dissolves in water
  • Good replacement for energy gels
CONS:
  • The package is sometimes hard to open

Bushwick Cinnamon Maple Syrup

OVERALL RATING 9.1
  • Editor’s Choice: Best Paleo-Friendly Maple Syrup
  • Syrup Grade: Grade A Amber; Organic
  • Available in: 13.5 oz
  • Bottling: Glass
  • Origin: Catskill Mountains, NY, the USA
  • Price: From $13.99 for a 13.5 oz bottle

Bushwick Kitchen is one of the more recent brands, but it has gained popularity rather quickly due to its interesting blends of flavors and aromas. What drives the owners is the belief that they should fill their bottles only with the best syrup.

This is another brand that is taking the traditional maple syrup to a whole new level with different spices and flavors. Harvested in the Catskill Mountains, its syrup packs a rich but not overwhelming maple taste.

Organic, gluten-free, and vegan, this is the bestrated maple syrup for anyone following the paleo diet. Plus, it still packs lots of flavor and a unique blend of aromas.

The organic cinnamon from Indonesia is mild but very present. The bottle is small, but it packs a lot of flavors that give a nice kick to any dish and complement the taste of the maple perfectly. The syrup also gives an excellent twist to cocktails and hot drinks.

PROS:
  • A unique blend of flavors
  • Gives food and drinks a twist
  • Organic cinnamon from Indonesia
CONS:
  • The packaging is too delicate and might break in transport

How to Choose the Best Maple Syrup

Not all maple syrup is made equally good, so here’s a short guide on what to look for when shopping for this sweet product.

Maple Syrup and Pancake Syrup Aren’t the Same

First things first, we need to clarify that maple syrup and pancake syrup aren’t the same. Yes, they typically sit side by side on a grocery shelf, and you use them both for your favorite breakfast food, but they couldn’t be more different.

The best pure maple syrup is made from maple tree sap that’s boiled down to a syrup. The water from the sap evaporates, and the natural sugars caramelize into the well-known golden color and characteristic flavor. Maple syrup is processed minimally.

In contrast to maple syrup, pancake syrup is a highly processed sweetener. It’s made primarily from corn syrup or corn syrup rich in fructose. It also has added coloring, flavors, and preservatives.

The syrups also differ in flavor. Fresh maple syrup has a clean maple flavor with a hint of vanilla, caramel, or prune. Unlike its maple counterpart, pancake syrup has a noticeably artificial flavor.

Who Should Use Maple Syrup?

Maple syrup is the right choice for everyone who wants to add a bit of sweetness to their food or meal replacement shakes without using too much processed sugar. It’s considered safe for everyone, even children and pregnant women.

It’s also suitable for anyone following the paleo diet and anyone who needs a replacement for cane sugar.

How to Find the Best Maple Syrup in the World

Unfortunately, not all maple syrup is 100% natural, so you should pay attention to a couple of things when looking for maple syrup:

Natural and Non-Natural

Now, a syrup of the highest quality should consist of 100% natural ingredients. Natural maple syrup is minimally processed. Hence it’s the healthiest option.

Unfortunately, many companies make false claims that their maple syrup is natural or organic. It’s always a good idea to check the product for certifications and go through the ingredients list.

Non-natural maple syrup often contains artificial sugars and fructose, which can be dangerous for people with diabetes.

Origin

The syrup’s origin is more important than you might think. Best-quality maple syrup comes from Quebec, Canada, and Vermont, US. These locations are widely known as the home of maple syrup.

The Grading System

The traditional grading system recognizes grade A and grade B maple syrup. It’s confusing to many people because it looks like the grades evaluate the syrup’s quality.

However, that’s not the case, as the grades refer to the syrup’s color and flavor.

Grade A maple syrup has a lighter color and a mild taste, while grade B maple syrup has a deep, dark color and intense flavor. Which one is the best maple syrup grade depends on your preference. Still, people usually prefer the more intense, grade B flavor.

The US Department of Agriculture changed the labeling system in 2015 to avoid any further confusion. There are now four labels that describe the syrup according to its flavor and color:

  • Grade A Golden Color/ Delicate Taste
  • Grade A Amber Color/ Rich Taste
  • Grade A Dark Color/ Robust Taste
  • Grade A Very Dark Color/ Strong Taste (former grade B).

However, despite the new labeling system, most maple syrup brands still use the traditional grading system.

Bottling

People usually don’t give the bottle much thought, but the type of bottle can affect the syrup’s taste and shelf life. Maple syrup is typically packed in a plastic or glass bottle.

A plastic bottle is more durable and convenient for shipping, but it can change the taste of a syrup slightly in some cases. It can also shorten the life shelf of the syrup.

That said, a glass bottle is delicate, but it doesn’t affect the shelf life or the syrup’s flavor.

Additives

Good maple syrup shouldn’t have any additives. Sadly, many companies add various preservatives, artificial sweeteners, coloring, and flavors to make their syrup taste or look better.

Benefits of Consuming Maple Syrup

Maple syrup is a natural sweetener, so it’s slightly better than regular sugar. It boasts incredible properties, including the ones below:

  • Maple syrup is less processed than regular sugar. The process of making maple syrup doesn’t involve chemicals.
  • Maple syrup is rich in manganese. One tablespoon of maple syrup provides 33% of the recommended daily intake of manganese. This mineral is essential for bone health, but it also eases osteoarthritis symptoms, and it is used in treating anemia.
  • The best natural maple syrup contains 22% of zinc’s RDI.
  • Maple syrup is rich in antioxidants. Researchers have found more than 20 different antioxidants in the syrup. They also discovered that darker-colored maple syrups are richer in antioxidants, hence have more anti-inflammatory benefits.

Possible Side Effects

Maple syrup is a natural sweetener, but it’s still sugar. Lots of minerals and antioxidants are great. But, consuming too much maple syrup, even the most organic pure maple syrup, can cause some side effects.

Consuming too much sugar (not only maple syrup) can cause or worsen:

  • Heart disease
  • Obesity
  • Type two diabetes

The Bottom Line

Maple syrup is a good way of adding a natural and slightly healthier sweetener to your diet. When consumed in moderation, it can bring in lots of antioxidants and minerals. Its unique flavor makes it an incredible addition to any dish — sweet or savory. 

Finally, our team hopes that these maple syrup reviews will help you find the best product to spice up your waffles, popcorn, bacon, or roasted veggies.

If you are still unsure which product to choose, you might want to acquaint yourself with customer reviews. More often than not, one can find a lot of useful information there. 

Now, let’s wrap things up with our FAQ section.

FAQs

What is the best maple syrup for pancakes?

It’s generally recommended that you use a lighter grade A maple syrup because its taste is milder and delicate but still rich. The best for that would be Mount Mansfield Maple Syrup, ChockZero Keto Maple Syrup, Runamok Barrel-Aged Maple Syrup, UnTapped, and Bushwick Kitchen Maple Syrup.

However, any maple syrup from our list is great for pancakes. You just need to decide whether you like a milder or a more robust, rich, and deep maple flavor.

Which is more healthy — maple syrup or honey?

Both honey and maple syrup are healthy natural sweeteners. When it comes to nutrition, honey contains more carbs, protein, and calories, whereas maple syrup contains more fat.

Neither contains cholesterol. However, maple syrup has a lower glycemic index than honey.

Honey is a better choice if you follow a low-fat diet. At the same time, maple syrup is better if you follow a low-calorie or low-carb diet or need a sweetener with a low glycemic index.

What’s the healthiest syrup?

Maple syrup, honey, agave syrup, molasses, and barley malt syrup are suitable substitutes for table sugar. However, the best offer is the one with a low glycemic index. What’s more, the syrup of your choice should be packed with minerals and antioxidants. Finally, the healthiest syrup is bound to be low in carbs and calories.

Which maple syrup is the best?

It depends on what you need and the maple syrup flavor you like. We have compiled the list of the best ones on the market. So, check out our reviews, and you’ll find the best maple syrup for all tastes and preferences.