The Best Meal Replacement Shakes in 2020 (Reviews & Guide)

Best Meal Replacement Shakes

With 1.9 billion adults being overweight, weight loss is one of the hot topics. That’s when meal replacement shakes come in. Interestingly, these shakes are much more than what meets the eye!

Meal replacements are a fantastic source of nutrients that’s quick to prepare. Whether you choose the one you need to stir (or shake) or the one that’s already prepared, we can all agree that taking these is more convenient than preparing a fully cooked meal.

Keep reading to learn more about the best meal replacement shakes you can find.

Top 10 Best Meal Replacement Shake Products to Buy This Year

Product
Rating
Key Features
Website
1
OVERALL RATING
10
Expert Review
  • Overall best meal replacement shakes
  • GMO-, gluten-, and soy-free
  • No growth hormones
  • Only 15 ingredients
FROM: $ 39.99
Visit Site
2
OVERALL RATING
10
Expert Review
  • Best protein meal replacement shakes
  • Digestive enzymes
  • Over 34g of protein per serving
  • Clean carbs
FROM: $ 59.99
Visit Site
3
OVERALL RATING
9.9
Expert Review
  • One of the best organic meal replacement shakes
  • 12 drinks in one pack
  • Kosher and vegetarian
  • Lightly sweetened
FROM: $ 29.99
Visit Site
4
OVERALL RATING
9.9
Expert Review
  • One of the best healthy meal replacement shakes
  • Nutrient-dense shake
  • Zero sugar
  • Versatile in its application
FROM: $ 49.99
Visit Site
5
OVERALL RATING
9.9
Expert Review
  • Best-tasting meal replacement shakes
  • Non-GMO
  • Organic
  • Certified vegan
FROM: $ 59.99
Visit Site
6
OVERALL RATING
9.8
Expert Review
  • Best keto meal replacement shakes for weight loss
  • Formulated by experts
  • Keto-, vegan-, and paleo-friendly
  • High bioavailability
FROM: $ 97.00
Visit Site
7
OVERALL RATING
9.8
Expert Review
  • Best meal replacement shakes for weight loss
  • Low in calories
  • High in fiber
  • Sustainable ingredients
FROM: $ 26.00
Visit Site
8
OVERALL RATING
9.7
Expert Review
  • Best vegan meal replacement shakes
  • Organic
  • On-the-go meal
  • Non-dairy
FROM: $ 27.99
Visit Site
9
OVERALL RATING
9.7
Expert Review
  • Best ready-to-drink meal replacement shakes
  • On-the-go keto meal
  • Clean ingredients
  • Formulated for lasting energy
FROM: $ 42.00
Visit Site
10
OVERALL RATING
9.7
Expert Review
  • Best low carb meal replacement shakes
  • Low-glycemic
  • No trans fat
  • Active enzymes
FROM: $ 55.99
Visit Site

Top 10 Meal Replacement Shakes Reviews

  • Price: $39.99
  • Servings per container: 26
  • Shipping policy: Free shipping on all orders over $49
  • Return policy: Unopened and unused items can be returned within 14 days for a full refund or exchange
  • Flavors: Unflavored

Naked Meal is the first meal replacement on our list that well-deserves that spot. It has no flavor, so you can easily accommodate it to your preference and needs.

One thing that makes this meal replacement stand out is that the company wants to stand by its name. It’s genuinely naked as it has only 15 premium ingredients, unlike other meal replacements that have many more. What’s more, the products are all clearly labeled, so you know what exactly you’re putting in your body.

According to meal replacement shakes reviews, there are no artificial flavors or fillers in this product, and you can tell that even by taste. 

To ensure good communication with its customers, Naked tries to provide the needed information as simple as possible. That means they try to avoid big and complicated words regular people might not understand.

What’s more, the product contains grass-fed whey from small dairy farms in the US. So, if you want to pick a company that gets its sources from local farmers, look no further than this selection of our meal replacement shakes reviews.

There is no soy or gluten in Naked Meal Meal Replacement, making it perfect for anyone who has some type of allergy or food intolerances. Even if you’re on a special diet, like keto, rest assured that this meal replacement is the right choice that won’t interfere with your weight loss process.

It’s the brand you can trust as you will know what you’re putting in your body while trying to lose weight as it’s perhaps the best meal replacement shake for weight loss on the market.

PROS:
  • Suitable for people with allergies
  • No fillers, artificial colors, or flavors
  • Great price-value ratio
CONS:
  • No flavors
  • Price: $59.99
  • Servings per container: 22
  • Shipping policy: Free shipping on orders over $30 with Subscribe & Gain
  • Return policy: You may return the product should you find yourself unsatisfied with it
  • Flavors: Chocolate and vanilla

Victus Meal Replacement is a meal replacement powder that comes in two classic flavors everyone likes—vanilla and chocolate. Just because you need to supplement your nutritional protocol doesn’t mean it can’t be quite tasty.

If you’re looking for the best meal replacement shakes for weight loss in 2020, you’re on the right track with this product.

You can buy it just once, or you can subscribe and get it every 30, 45, 60, or 90 days. It all depends on how much you need, and it saves you the trouble of remembering to order it. 

This way, you will never run out of the product, and you will always get it in time for the next refill. All of that comes with free shipping, so you aren’t subject to extra costs. That’s honestly an outstanding price-value ratio.

You just need to mix two scoops of powder with some water or other drink and shake it (or stir it) to get your best-tasting meal replacement shakes for weight loss.

This meal replacement contains digestive enzymes, which help the body break down foods. It also contains a full spectrum of vitamins and minerals for optimal health.

It’s high in protein, at 35g per serving, and it also contains clean carbs, which makes it the perfect meal replacement. Even though no returns are currently accepted at Bodybuilding.com, you will get a full refund should you find yourself unsatisfied with the product.

If you follow the recommendations stated on the packaging, the product will last you three weeks or more, adding to its price-value ratio.

PROS:
  • Long-lasting
  • Great subscription program
  • Good for digestion
CONS:
  • Lack of flavors
  • Price: $29.99
  • Servings per container: 12
  • Shipping policy: Free standard shipping for a limited time to the 48 Contiguous States
  • Return policy: Contact Organic within 30 days of receiving its product for a refund
  • Flavors: Creamy Chocolate Fudge, Strawberries and Cream, Iced Cafe Mocha, Sweet Vanilla Bean

Organic Grass-Fed All-In-One Nutritional Shake is one of the most conveniently packaged meal replacement shakes that taste good and are entirely organic. 

It comes in 12 drinks per pack, so every serving is already prepared. You don’t have to bother calculating the proper dosage. For those who want an auto-delivery, you even get a 20% discount.

There are four different flavors to choose from, so you don’t have to worry about not liking the taste. Whether it’s Creamy Chocolate Fudge, Strawberries and Cream, Iced Cafe Mocha, or Sweet Vanilla Bean, we are certain that one of these best meal replacement shakes will be right up your alley.

This nutritional shake is high in protein and contains a whopping 21 vitamins and minerals. It has enough proteins, fat, and carbohydrates to ensure you satisfy your nutritional needs. 

If you need to go on a special diet or you are already on one, this is one of the healthiest meal replacement shakes. It’s also gluten-free, kosher, and vegetarian. Sadly, it does include milk; thus, it might not be for you if you are lactose intolerant.

PROS:
  • Great for special diets
  • Helps you build muscles
  • Convenient, on-the-go packaging
CONS:
  • Contains milk
  • Price: $49.99
  • Servings per container: 20
  • Shipping policy: Free shipping for A1 Plus members
  • Return policy: No returns on opened products
  • Flavors: Chocolate Milk

A complete and nutrient-dense protein meal replacement, GCode Nutrition Feast, is one of the best meal replacement shakes for men and women.

This meal replacement comes in a 1.6 lb packaging, and you can use it for 20 servings. That means it’ll last you a long time, and you will save money. 

It’s a full serving of greens that’s high in protein and contains the best macro- and micronutrient ingredients. To make your digestion easier, this meal replacement has both digestive enzymes and probiotics. That makes it a fantastic choice, even for professional athletes.

Those of you who might be worried about sugar or artificial flavors and colors can rest assured—there is none of it in this shake.

Despite it being an excellent choice for athletes, it doesn’t mean it’s not one of the best diet meal replacement shakes for regular people too. In fact, it is created with real people in the real world in mind.

PROS:
  • Great for digestion
  • Versatile in its application
  • No sugar or artificial flavors
CONS:
  • No returns on opened products
  • Price: $59.99
  • Servings per container: 20
  • Shipping policy: Free shipping within the US on orders over $75
  • Return policy: 100% money-back guarantee
  • Flavors: Chocolate, Vanilla, and Unflavored

Superfood Protein – 20 Serving Jug is, as the name suggests, truly a superfood. It comes in two flavors that everyone likes—chocolate and vanilla. However, if you prefer your meal to have no added taste, look no further as there is an unflavored option, too.

It’s a plant-based nutritional shake that contains proteins, greens, fiber, fats, vitamins, minerals, and digestive enzymes for easy and healthy digestion. With 20g of protein per serving, it’s high in protein, making it one of the best meal replacement shakes for women and men.

Those who consider using this meal replacement for a longer time might want to take up a 20% discount following the subscription. With a low price like that and 20 servings per container, Superfood Protein is a pretty good deal with a great price-value ratio.

What makes this meal replacement reliable is its organic nature—the product is vegan, gluten-free, and GMO-free. With this product that made it to our meal replacement shakes reviews, you can be sure that you only get high-quality supplements.

To top it all, Superfood Protein doesn’t even contain sugar, soy, and whey. What’s more, unlike many other meal replacements, it doesn’t contain dairy. That makes it perfect for people with allergies.

If all of that wasn’t enough to convince you, this meal replacement was voted the best-tasting plant-based protein. On top of that, many customers have claimed that Superfood Protein was one of the best-tasting meal replacement shakes they’ve ever tried.

PROS:
  • Great return policy
  • Amazing taste
  • Many certifications and verifications that ensure safety and quality
CONS:
  • Not many flavor choices
  • Price: $97.00
  • Servings per container: 30
  • Shipping policy: $9 for priority shipping and $15 for 2-day expedited shipping in the US
  • Return policy: 60-day money-back guarantee
  • Flavors: Natural flavor

Athletic Greens might seem quite expensive at first glance. That said, once you look closer, you’ll realize it’s well worth the money as it is one of the top meal replacement shakes on the market.

It’s packaged in a 12.7 oz pouch and is suitable for 30 days of serving. That means that you don’t have to worry about getting another one for an entire month. 

What makes it even better is that you can subscribe and save 21%, with an option to cancel subscription anytime. If you want individual serving packaging, you can choose that option.  

The Athletic Greens is easy to digest thanks to its highly absorbable ingredients. That should come as no surprise, seeing how doctors, nutritionists, and naturopaths formulated it. 

It will not only help you with digestion but also strengthen your immunity, boost your energy, and speed up your recovery as well—making it one of the best ready-to-drink meal replacement shakes

Those of you who look into supplements will probably like the fact that it is paleo-, keto-, and vegan-friendly, as well as low in allergens. That means it doesn’t contain dairy, wheat, gluten,  animal products, artificial colors, and added sugar.

PROS:
  • Low allergen
  • Travel packs
  • Good for the immune system, energy, and digestion
CONS:
  • High price
  • Price: $26–$130
  • Servings per container: Varies by the container (from 8 to 67 servings)
  • Shipping policy: International shipping from €6 (around $9)
  • Return policy: Up to 365 days to return the product
  • Flavors: 15 different flavors

If you want more choices in sizes and flavors, Diet Meal Replacement Extreme is for you. You can pick one of 15 flavors and 4 different sizes of packages. Besides, who says you can’t try all the flavors and pick several best meal replacement shakes at once?

It’s high in protein with 24g per serving, and it’s high in fiber—5.4g per serving. That means your body will quickly process the ingredients, and you won’t feel hungry after. It’s great if you’re trying to lose weight.

It will even help you maintain muscle mass. So not only you’ll finally feel full, but it’ll also help you lose weight, making Diet Meal Replacement one of the best weight loss shakes

We have tried it ourselves and were impressed by the results. Of course, it’s not magical, but we have started to lose weight and gain muscle more quickly with changing nothing in our schedule besides adding this meal replacement. 

However, that’s not all this meal replacement has to offer. It’s completely vegetarian and contains sustainable ingredients. That makes it eco-friendly, and if you want to support a good cause, this is a great way to do it.

If you still need more supporting evidence, know that this meal replacement contains whey protein, making it one of the best meal replacement protein shakes for weight loss. 

So, help your immune system and get your energy boosted with this nutritionally complete meal. You can safely use it with other supplements.  

However, all of these fantastic features do come at a price as it is rather expensive. That said, in this case, the price is indeed justified.

PROS:
  • Environmentally friendly
  • Great for weight loss
  • Huge variety of flavors
CONS:
  • A bit pricey
  • Price: $27.99–$30.81
  • Servings per container: About 16 servings
  • Shipping policy: Free shipping
  • Return policy: Varies by seller
  • Flavors: Vanilla and chocolate

Orgain Organic Plant-Based Meal Replacement Powder is one of the best organic meal replacement shakes. With plant-based protein, fiber, and no sugar, it’s highly nutritious, and it’s even suitable for children.

It comes in two delicious flavors, chocolate and vanilla, and you only need two scoops per serving. That means it’ll last you a long time and save you money.

What’s more, you can use it for smoothies or as an on-the-go meal, before or after a workout. It’s, hands down, one of the most versatile meal replacements on our list.

Many best meal replacement shakes are plant-based, and thus, vegetarian. However, not many are vegan-friendly like this one. Orgain Organic Plant-Based Meal Replacement Powder contains many organic sprouts, greens, fruits, and vegetables. 

The fact that it’s labeled organic means it comes from a truly reliable source. Besides, this meal replacement contains no artificial flavors, colors, or preservatives. 

If you are allergic to soy, dairy, or gluten, rest assured this meal replacement is safe for you as it contains none of it. What’s more, it’s GMO-free, which places this product among the top 10 meal replacement shakes.

All in all, if you need a highly nutritious meal wherever you are, Orgain Organic should be the meal replacement of your choice.

PROS:
  • Appropriate even for children
  • Formulated by doctors
  • Vegan
CONS:
  • Sometimes tastes somewhat odd
  • Price: $42–$84
  • Servings per container: 1 serving per bottle
  • Shipping policy: Free shipping
  • Return policy: Varies by seller
  • Flavors: Berry, chocolate, vanilla, vanilla cinnamon

Ample Meal Replacement Shake is a meal replacement that is a complete and nutritious replacement for your daily diet. If you’re looking to add a couple of pounds, this is among the best meal replacement shakes for weight gain. With the regular-sized shake, you will get a whopping 400 calories per serving! What’s more, this shake is a fantastic substitute for breakfast or lunch as it keeps you focused for at least four hours. 

Conscious consumers would be glad to discover that this replacement meal contains carefully sourced ingredients. Among its real-food ingredients are coconut, macadamia nuts, and grass-fed whey. What’s more, the product is free of artificial flavors, sweeteners, and sugar alcohols.

This meal replacement is your go-to if you’re a busy person with no time to spare. The product comes in a convenient bottle and is incredible for those on the go.

If you are looking for the best meal replacement shakes not for weight loss, you might also check out a large-sized Ample Meal Replacement Shake that provides an astounding 600 calories in a single serving! 

By and large, if you’re trying to gain weight, Ample Meal Replacement in a Bottle is something for you to look into.

PROS:
  • Boosting energy
  • Great for weight gain
  • Amazing taste and texture
CONS:
  • Pricey
  • Price: $55.99
  • Servings per container 14
  • Shipping policy: Varies by the cost of the order
  • Return policy: 30 days from the date of purchase
  • Flavors: Creamy Dutch Chocolate, Creamy French Vanilla, Strawberry Cream, Chocolate Mint, Natural Creamy Vanilla – Kosher

Another perfect meal replacement, Isagenix IsaLean Shake, is both nutritious and balanced. It comes in a variety of flavors and is suitable for replacing 14 meals.

This meal replacement contains many healthy and useful ingredients, making it ideal for helping you lose weight and placing the product among the best meal replacement shakes for women’s and men’s weight loss.

If you want to build lean muscles, the product will most certainly help you out as it contains amino acids and high-quality proteins.

It’s low-glycemic; however, since it contains protein and carbohydrates, this meal replacement will boost your energy. What’s more, healthy fats, vitamins, and minerals in this shake will strengthen your overall health. There are also no artificial flavors, colors, or sweeteners; it only contains natural ingredients.

Its active enzymes will help your digestion and make it easier for you to lose weight and become or stay fit, making Isagenix IsaLean shakes another good meal replacement shakes for weight loss.

This meal replacement is also one of the more versatile ones. Not only can it completely replace your meal and make your life easier as on-the-go nourishment, but it will also help you achieve your ideal body goals.

PROS:
  • Great return policy
  • Good for losing weight
  • Completely natural
CONS:
  • Some customers complained that the texture was somewhat odd

How We Ranked the Products in Our Meal Replacement Shakes Reviews

We know it can be hard to pick the best from the rest. That’s why we decided to do the job for you, backed by our extensive knowledge.

To rank all the meal replacement products, we have used specific criteria to determine the top-rated meal replacement shakes.

Price-Value Ratio

All of us want to get what we paid for. Unfortunately, sometimes it turns out we have only wasted our money.

If we want to lose or gain weight, we want the product to do the job. At the same time, we also want to stay within our budget and get our money’s worth.

That’s why we have carefully chosen the best meal replacement shakes that are top-notch quality and affordable at the same time.

Ingredients

It’s important to know what you put in your body. Some companies try to conceal some information using big and complicated words. Most people don’t have time to do proper, thorough research. That’s why we have done it for you.

User Reviews

If you want an honest, unbiased meal replacement shakes review, consumers’ reviews are your go-to. They will tell it how it really is. Unlike the companies that sell these products, consumers don’t have a reason to lie as they don’t gain anything from it.

That’s why we went through customer reviews to see if meal replacements really work as their respective companies claim. For example, we went through some meal replacement shakes reviews to see if they actually help you lose weight, or if it’s just a marketing gimmick.

Intake Frequency

As we have said, we understand many people don’t have time. It’s hard to fit in proper nourishment when snowed under with tons of work. We don’t want to spend half the day thinking if we have taken all the shakes we needed for that day.

That’s why we searched for top meal replacement shakes that take the least amount of your time to prepare and can be taken once a day. 

Packaging

We know most of you lead busy lives and have no time to waste with packages that need to be cut open and sealed with something else each time, or maybe even put somewhere else to be stored. 

Maybe you don’t have enough space for large packages. Maybe you simply travel a lot, so you need multiple small packages to have a ready-to-drink shake on you at all times. 

All of that was taken into consideration when compiling this list.

How to Buy the Best Meal Replacement Protein Shakes for Your Needs

After going through all top-notch meal replacement shakes currently on the market, you’re probably wondering how to choose the best one. Well, don’t worry. We know what you should take into consideration. Keep reading to find out.

Type of Packaging

Typically, the best diet meal replacements shakes come in containers. That means you have to put the right amount of powder in the water or some other drink, then stir it or shake it. That’s usually not a problem if you’re mostly drinking it at home or maybe even at the office.

However, some people are always on the go, and those types of packages are not the most convenient. Some of you might travel once in a while, or quite often, and you want something that’s easy to carry. 

In that case, you might want to consider travel-friendly packages—one small container for one serving, and you can easily pack it anywhere.

Formula

The best weight loss shakes use only high-quality ingredients. If you’re vegan or vegetarian, you will want to check if the product of your choice uses any animal products. 

If you have allergies, check for allergens. Considering 150–200 people die in the US each year because of food allergies, allergens in food aren’t to be taken lightly. 

Avoid products that contain artificial flavor or colors and look for those that contain natural ingredients. If you want to be sure you’re providing your body with the best nutrition, choose meal replacements with clear ingredients labels.

Purpose

Most top-rated meal replacement shakes serve a particular purpose. In other words, they aren’t just there to conveniently replace your meal but rather to help you with weight loss and muscle gain. While weight loss pills are the go-to for many, meal replacement shakes are starting to make it to the shelf of more and more consumers. 

Some shakes might be even for weight gain, while some are perfect for replacing your special diet. For example, if you have diabetes, you might want to look for healthy meal replacement shakes formulated specifically for people with diabetes.

Another group that could most certainly benefit from meal replacement shakes—those in their advanced years. Older people tend to suffer from chronic conditions that ask for easier meal consumption. And, you guessed it, that’s when easily digestible meal replacement shakes come to rescue. 

Protein Shake vs. Meal Replacement

Many confuse these two. Protein shakes are supposed to give you more protein and are nothing more than a supplement. You take them before or after a workout, but you still eat your meals normally.

Healthy meal replacement shakes can fully replace one or two of your daily meals. Unlike protein shakes that are mostly just that—proteins, meal replacement includes different nutrients, including minerals and vitamins. Please note that you might want to turn to a specific vitamin supplement or a multivitamin to get the nutrients you need if you have a vitamin deficiency. 

By and large, do keep in mind that some meal replacements are versatile and can be used like protein shakes, but not vice versa. 

Conclusion

Now that you have gone through our best meal replacement shakes list, we are confident you will know what to look for.

Whether you’re looking for products for weight loss or just shakes that taste good, you will find them all here. So, why don’t you choose one of the meal replacement shakes from our list?

FAQs

What is the best meal replacement shake for weight loss?

We consider Diet Meal Replacement Extreme to be the best for weight loss. However, if you don’t like something in its formula, there are many good ones to choose from our list to help you lose weight.

Are meal replacement shakes good for weight loss?

Many of them are. You just have to check the description on the official website or the product’s packaging. On our list, we have many shakes created to help you lose weight, among other things.

What are the best meal replacement shakes?

Here we have compiled a list of the best meal replacements, based on our expert knowledge. To choose the one that will be the best for you, check out our Buyer’s Guide.

Are protein shakes good as a meal replacement?

No, they aren’t. Protein shakes are supposed to be used only as supplements, for example, before or after a workout. They can’t replace one or two of your three daily meals, unlike the best meal replacement shakes.